Precepts-Not-Politics: Aid, Life and Death

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Chikyou
    Member
    • May 2022
    • 711

    #46
    Originally posted by Jundo
    Precepts-Not-Politics ... stories like this, human lives at risk, are the concern. Was there no better way than turning off the aid at once? How many children and others will die? Assuming these reports are true, it represents the effects in just one corner of the world ...

    ~~~
    No doctors for sick children. This is the reality of Trump’s aid freeze in remote northern Thailand

    ... When the Trump administration ordered a 90-day freeze on almost all international aid, halting the US’ entire global development network overnight, the camp hospital was forced to shut its doors, sending shock waves through the refugee community.

    Video posted by refugees on social media showed patients at the center being lifted from their hospital beds and carried out in hammocks covered in blankets.

    Rosella was moved to a nearby improvised health center, along with other patients with chronic conditions. But there are no longer any doctors to treat her.

    Numerous aid workers in northern Thailand described widespread panic and confusion following the sudden suspension of aid, especially among those whose work provides life-saving services to some of the world’s most vulnerable and impoverished people on both sides of the border.

    Some told CNN they only had a month and a half of funding left to feed tens of thousands of people.

    “We have never faced a problem like this before,” said Saw Bweh Say, secretary of the Karen Refugee Committee, which represents refugees in the Thai camps. ... Basic services such as health care, education, sanitation, water and food are provided by international aid donors. In Mae La, and six other camps, those funds come almost entirely from the US – the world’s largest aid donor – through the International Rescue Committee.

    Though the camp hospitals are more akin to field clinics, with tin roofs and intermittent power, they are the only source of health care for tens of thousands of people.

    “If it’s an emergency, how can we face the situation? That burdens a lot of people here,” said Ni Ni, 62, who has heart failure and kidney disease.

    Without medical oxygen, “I will die,” she told CNN via video call from Mae La.​

    ...

    An IRC spokesperson said they had to start shutting outpatient departments and other facilities in the camps following the stop-work order. Management of the medical facilities, equipment and water system has been transferred to Thai authorities and camp commanders, though the IRC continues to source medicine and fuel using non-US funds.

    Teams of refugee medics, midwives and nurses are working round-the-clock helping to plug the gaps, while families scramble for alternative treatment for their loved ones.

    “Karen families donated medicine and oxygen tanks, but that’s not enough,” said Pim Kerdsawang, an independent NGO worker in the border city of Mae Sot.

    Compounding their concerns is the cost of food. Feeding more than 100,000 refugees across all nine camps for one month costs $1.3 million dollars, and the organization that provides the food and cooking fuel says it has only enough money to last for a month and a half.​

    ...

    The pain created by the US aid freeze goes beyond the refugee camps.

    CNN spoke to about a dozen NGO and aid workers in the impoverished border region, some of whom requested anonymity as they feared reprisals from the US government, who said basic services were disrupted and staff laid off due to the Trump administration’s policy.

    They include cuts to vaccine, education and resettlement programs, domestic violence shelters, anti-human-trafficking initiatives, safe houses for dissidents, and help for displaced people.​

    Aid workers in northern Thailand described widespread confusion following the US aid freeze, especially among those whose work provides life-saving services to some of the world’s most vulnerable and impoverished people


    Gassho, J
    stlah
    This is horrific, truly. I actually had no idea that the US was funding entire medical systems overseas (I support us doing so, I was simply unaware. I’m more aware of our less humanitarian actions. So I’m pleased to read that we were doing so much, and angry to learn that its been cut off suddenly and without warning.)

    Gassho,
    SatLah,
    Chikyō
    Chikyō 知鏡
    (Wisdom Mirror)
    They/Them

    Comment

    • Shoshin
      Member
      • Jul 2024
      • 291

      #47
      Originally posted by Chikyou

      This is horrific, truly. I actually had no idea that the US was funding entire medical systems overseas (I support us doing so, I was simply unaware. I’m more aware of our less humanitarian actions. So I’m pleased to read that we were doing so much, and angry to learn that its been cut off suddenly and without warning.)

      Gassho,
      SatLah,
      Chikyō
      Yes, the United States has been the biggest donor in international Aid in absolute numbers.
      But I think it's important to put this in context, because it makes it all even sadder:

      The economic effort that the US Aid represents is really minimal compared to that of countries with smaller economies.

      I'll copy another comment I made somewhere else:

      "Many other countries are already contributing with a much larger % of their gross national income (GNI). The States contribute with a very very small % but because of the size of it's economy ends (ended...) up being the bigger donor. Unfortunately I don't think other countries are going to make up for what the States will stop spending in Aid. For those that think that the United States have been
      making an economic big effort with their development Aid the following numbers will probably be shocking:


      "Luxembourg made the largest contribution as a percentage of gross national income (GNI) at 1.05% and the United Nations’ ODA target of 0.7% of GNI was also exceeded by Norway (1.02%), Sweden (0.99%) and Denmark (0.71%).[1] The European Union accumulated a higher portion of GDP as a form of foreign aid than any other economic union.[2]

      The United States is a small contributor relative to GNI (0.22% 2022[3]) but is the largest single DAC donor of ODA in 2022 (US$55.3 billion) followed by Germany (0.8% GNI, US$35.0 billion), France (0.7%, US$19.5 billion), Japan (0.3%, US$17.3 billion) and the United Kingdom (0.5%, US$15.7 billion).[4"

      As an interesting comparison, India contributes with a 0.65 % of their GDP..."

      Another interesting comparison: the US population is around 342.000.000 people.
      Germany has 84.000.00 inhabitants
      France 66.500.000

      Gassho,
      Satlah


      ​​
      ​​​​
      Last edited by Shoshin; 02-12-2025, 06:34 PM.
      Shōshin - Pine Heart 松心

      Comment

      • Ddixon
        Member
        • Jan 2025
        • 14

        #48
        Originally posted by Shoshin

        I appreciate that your comment comes from a place of respect and willingness to understand one another.
        I see things differently and I suspect that one of the main reasons might be that we have access to different informations and pieces of news. So, we reach different conclusions. Isn't it scary?
        It makes me be interested and curious about reading the US media.
        ​​​​Many thanks for sharing your thoughts

        Gassho
        Satlah
        ​​​​​
        I am sorry that I have not responded to this sooner. Your suspicion is correct that my information and understanding comes from different sources. I actually do not watch any news media outlet because depending on which one the opinions are biased towards their base. When I was active duty, I would get the daily classified briefs of what was happening around the world. I was shocked at how much was kept away from the public for worry it would cause fear and panic. I have also witnessed complete shutdown of stories by the government. I guarantee most people do not know about the USS Paul Hamilton being attacked. If you look it up today, it will just say a collision at sea, which is not the whole story. I know about this, because I was on the ship at the time it was attacked.

        I follow the principle of Buddhist teachings. Of not believing anything that I have not investigated. Following the Regan belief of "Trust, but verify" is a huge motto in the military. I look for original documents, in this case executive orders, bills or laws listed on the congressional sites among other places to get the full information without others opinions and assess it critically.

        I know we may disagree with some things, and that is okay, I would like to think you for the civil discourse in discussing the similarities and differences.

        Gassho,

        Douglas

        SATLAH
        Bhavatu sabba mangalam,
        rakkhantu sabba devata,
        sabba buddhānubhāvena sadā sotthī bhavantu te.

        Comment

        • Shoshin
          Member
          • Jul 2024
          • 291

          #49
          Originally posted by Ddixon

          I am sorry that I have not responded to this sooner. Your suspicion is correct that my information and understanding comes from different sources. I actually do not watch any news media outlet because depending on which one the opinions are biased towards their base. When I was active duty, I would get the daily classified briefs of what was happening around the world. I was shocked at how much was kept away from the public for worry it would cause fear and panic. I have also witnessed complete shutdown of stories by the government. I guarantee most people do not know about the USS Paul Hamilton being attacked. If you look it up today, it will just say a collision at sea, which is not the whole story. I know about this, because I was on the ship at the time it was attacked.

          I follow the principle of Buddhist teachings. Of not believing anything that I have not investigated. Following the Regan belief of "Trust, but verify" is a huge motto in the military. I look for original documents, in this case executive orders, bills or laws listed on the congressional sites among other places to get the full information without others opinions and assess it critically.

          I know we may disagree with some things, and that is okay, I would like to think you for the civil discourse in discussing the similarities and differences.

          Gassho,

          Douglas

          SATLAH
          Very interesting, thanks for sharing.
          "Trust, but verify". Good motto.

          Nice to have you in the Sangha

          Gassho,
          Satlah

          Shōshin - Pine Heart 松心

          Comment

          Working...