Precepts-Not-Politics: Aid, Life and Death

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Jundo
    Treeleaf Founder and Priest
    • Apr 2006
    • 41097

    Precepts-Not-Politics: Aid, Life and Death

    Dear All,

    Master Dogen quoted Master Eisai, " The Buddha cut off his flesh and limbs and offered them to living beings. Even if we gave the whole body of the Buddha to people who are about to die of starvation, such an action would certainly be in accordance with the Buddha’s will.” He went on, “Even if I fall into hell because of this sin, I have just saved living beings from starvation." ... "To miss a day’s food, or even to starve to death, should not bother you. It is more beneficial to save people in the secular world right now who are suffering from a lack of something they need.” (Zuimonki 2-2, 6-15)

    As we discuss here from time to time, overt politics is avoided at Treeleaf, and "left at the Sangha door," so that we can sit and practice beyond views. However, certain topics press upon the Precepts, including our Vow to avoid the taking of life, and to rescue sentient beings. It is a thin line to tread, but I believe that this is a case where protest and concern must be raised because lives are at stake, including the lives of children.

    Taking these effects as likely, the cutting off of aid to leave people in poverty, hunger, homelessness and without medical care and other resources is immoral by anything but the darkest interpretation of our Vows and general humane values. It must be protested by ethical people of all peaceful, caring humane creeds and philosophies.

    Petitions and marches may have no effect. Words from the pulpit will not be heard. It may come time for citizen's civil disobedience as our only response, for lives are at stake.

    Gassho, Jundo
    stlah

    Charities reeling from USAid freeze warn of ‘life or death’ effects

    Abrupt order has done ‘serious damage’, say experts, with supply chains halted, HIV clinics struggling to source drugs and refugee camps facing loss of vital services


    Clinics in Uganda are scrambling to find new sources for vital HIV drugs, aid workers in Bangladesh fear refugee camp infrastructure will crumble, and mobile health units may have to stop treating civilians near the frontline in Ukraine.

    Services worldwide have been thrown into disarray by President Donald Trump’s executive order, signed on Monday 20 January and published on Friday halting US foreign aid funding flows for 90 days for review.

    A few exemptions include military aid to Israel and emergency humanitarian food assistance, but charities said the sudden announcement – which included instructions for any US-funded work already in progress to stop immediately – had put lives at risk.

    The US president’s Emergency Plan for Aids Relief (Pepfar) is included in the order. It provides antiretrovirals to 20 million people with HIV globally, and funds test kits and preventive medicine supplies for millions more.

    Already, clinics worldwide are reporting that supplies have been halted.

    “This is a matter of life or death,” said Beatriz Grinsztejn, president of the International Aids Society, adding that stopping Pepfar would be disastrous. “If that happens, people are going to die and HIV will resurge.”

    Brian Aliganyira runs a health clinic for the LGBT+ community in Kampala, Uganda. He said the presidential order had brought supplies to a standstill. Ark Wellness Hub relies on Pepfar for testing kits, medication to prevent and treat HIV and running costs.

    “Today is crazy,” he said on Monday. “We are worried. As I’m chatting with you now, I’m amid lots of emails and trying to find who can stock up our supplies and drugs. Supply chains [are] all affected.”

    ...

    There has been concern about the impacts of the cuts on hundreds of refugee camps globally – from Chad to Nigeria – where displaced people are especially reliant on aid.

    A million people live in sprawling camps in Bangladesh, where the US provided 55% of funding for the Rohingya humanitarian response and which had already seen a drop in funding last year. An aid worker there, who wished to remain anonymous, said they were assessing “what are the most critical life-saving activities to prioritise”.

    ...

    It will also affect programmes monitoring the spread of bird flu, and working to eradicate polio and tropical diseases such as river blindness and lymphatic filariasis, he said, as well as services providing healthcare for pregnant women and childhood vaccinations.

    ...

    The One campaign, co-founded in 2004 by the U2 singer Bono, estimated that nearly 3 million children could be at higher risk of malaria if the president’s malaria initiative paused work for 90 days.

    Thomas Byrnes, who runs a consulting firm specialising in the humanitarian sector, said the sudden stop-work orders would have a harsh, far-reaching impact because of the extent the global system relies on US funding. The US provides 42.3% of global aid funding, according to the UN, and as much as 54% of the World Food Programme’s funding.

    MORE HERE: https://www.theguardian.com/global-d...-death-effects

    Last edited by Jundo; 02-05-2025, 05:54 AM.
    ALL OF LIFE IS OUR TEMPLE
  • Onkai
    Senior Priest-in-Training
    • Aug 2015
    • 3169

    #2
    I live in a bubble. This saddens me. Thank you, Jundo, for bringing to our attention the plight of people affected by cutting off aid.

    Gassho Onkai
    美道 Bidou Beautiful Way
    恩海 Onkai Merciful/Kind Ocean

    I have a lot to learn; take anything I say that sounds like teaching with a grain of salt.

    Comment

    • Junsho
      Member
      • Mar 2024
      • 194

      #3
      Like Onkai, as a diligent student, I try to keep myself out of politics. In general I just observe the movements around and try to not judge.

      However, It seems to me impossible not see that the recent times are being very though for the beings living in this little planet. War everywhere (now it is starting a new one in Ruanda against Congo and nobody is talking about it), diseases, poverty and egoism seems to take more and more place in human societies. I pray for people have more compassion and be aware the interconnection of all beings.

      Gassho!
      SatLah
      Junshō 純聲 - Pure Voice, Genuine Speech
      ​​​​​​
      If you meet the Buddha on the road, kill him.” - Linji Yixuan​​

      Comment

      • Mujin
        Member
        • Jul 2023
        • 82

        #4
        There are also MANY issues with USAID that need to be addressed, this is also true. However, those can be looked at while maintaining the important work of the organization. It doesnt need to be an all or nothing approach. As usual, politicians show they have a very limited ability to actually think.

        Gassho,

        John

        SatTodayLAH

        Comment

        • Hosai
          Member
          • Jun 2024
          • 691

          #5
          In other words, the "preceptual" IS the political...?

          It's never so simple.

          I worked for 3 years as a settlement worker for immigrants to Canada.

          I also founded a bicycle co-op which served an emergency shelter and the "Working poor"

          This set up a dichotomy for me between those who are seen as deserving aid and those who are not and what the basis for this was (AND IT WAS ALWAYS POLITICAL).

          I could write several lengthy papers on this so I won't bore you. But it might interest you to think about who are the deserving of help and who are not...

          Modern Interpretations
          Even today, many social policies reflect this distinction, often implicitly:

          1. Deserving Poor:

          Individuals with disabilities

          The elderly

          Children

          Widows or single parents (in some perspectives)

          Those who work but still struggle (the "working poor")


          These groups are often seen as victims of circumstance and, therefore, worthy of government or charitable support.


          2. Non-Deserving Poor:

          Those perceived as unwilling to work despite being able-bodied

          People struggling with addiction

          Long-term welfare recipients

          Those who engage in criminal behavior


          These individuals are often judged as having made bad choices and, therefore, are seen as less deserving of support.

          How you choose who to help based on your observance of the precepts also indicates your politics.

          Who deserves my chunk of flesh that I cut off my own body and who gets to decide?

          _/\_
          sat/ah
          hōsai


          Last edited by Hosai; 02-05-2025, 02:22 PM.

          Comment

          • Shinshi
            Senior Priest-in-Training
            • Jul 2010
            • 3801

            #6
            Thank you Jundo. That is a wonderful post. I have seen first hand the wonderful work that USAID as accomplished. And the current situation is heartbreaking.

            Gassho, Shinshi

            SaT-LaH
            空道 心志 Kudo Shinshi

            For Zen students a weed is a treasure. With this attitude, whatever you do, life becomes an art.
            ​— Shunryu Suzuki

            E84I - JAJ

            Comment

            • Meishin
              Member
              • May 2014
              • 874

              #7
              Thank you, Jundo. Yes it's heartbreaking and yours is a timely post about an executive action that was suggested in advance -- among many, many more that the current administration has and is expected to take. However I'm not sure what you are suggesting with "citizen's civil disobedience." Could you flesh that out? Should I withhold taxes that will be at the bequest of the Texas Governor and Legislature to cause pain and suffering to my neighbors?

              Gassho
              Meishin
              stlah

              Comment

              • Hoseki
                Member
                • Jun 2015
                • 698

                #8
                Originally posted by Meishin
                Thank you, Jundo. Yes it's heartbreaking and yours is a timely post about an executive action that was suggested in advance -- among many, many more that the current administration has and is expected to take. However I'm not sure what you are suggesting with "citizen's civil disobedience." Could you flesh that out? Should I withhold taxes that will be at the bequest of the Texas Governor and Legislature to cause pain and suffering to my neighbors?

                Gassho
                Meishin
                stlah
                Meishin,

                You must have quite the tax bill if withholding it will cause that much trouble for the State Jokes aside, it's often difficult to identify specific actions one can take and historically civil disobedience has taken many forms. In most instances, it's a collective action of some kind so you probably won't have to think something up yourself and when the opportunities arises you will have to size up whether or not it's the right thing for you to do. There could be many good reasons not to take part. Sometimes civil disobedience is violent and bloody (which I'm sure we all here would avoid) while other times its sitting on the whites only section of a bus, or even as saving and trading seeds used to grow food. I would think this is just a case of what and see what other people are doing.

                Gassho,
                Hoseki
                sattoday/lah

                Comment

                • Hosai
                  Member
                  • Jun 2024
                  • 691

                  #9
                  My former teacher at Treetop Zen Center, Peter Whol, was arrested several times while being engaged in civil disobedience (I think he and Blanche Hartman ended up in a cell together for a while). I haven't been arrested yet but I love a good protest (and I guarantee you there's some big ones coming).

                  Have some values worth being arrested for!

                  ​​​_/\_
                  sat/ah
                  hōsai
                  Last edited by Hosai; 02-05-2025, 08:56 PM.

                  Comment

                  • Hosai
                    Member
                    • Jun 2024
                    • 691

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Onkai
                    I live in a bubble. This saddens me. Thank you, Jundo, for bringing to our attention the plight of people affected by cutting off aid.

                    Gassho Onkai
                    Just wondering Onkai , What do you mean by living in a bubble?

                    _/\_
                    sat/ah
                    hōsai

                    Comment

                    • Onkai
                      Senior Priest-in-Training
                      • Aug 2015
                      • 3169

                      #11
                      Originally posted by Hosai

                      Just wondering Onkai , What do you mean by living in a bubble?

                      _/\_
                      sat/ah
                      hōsai
                      Well, I read the news, but live in a happy corner of the world. I don't always let the world situation touch me. It is devastating that health aid is being cut off around the world.

                      Gassho Onkai
                      美道 Bidou Beautiful Way
                      恩海 Onkai Merciful/Kind Ocean

                      I have a lot to learn; take anything I say that sounds like teaching with a grain of salt.

                      Comment

                      • Hosai
                        Member
                        • Jun 2024
                        • 691

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Onkai

                        Well, I read the news, but live in a happy corner of the world. I don't always let the world situation touch me. It is devastating that health aid is being cut off around the world.

                        Gassho Onkai
                        Oh so maybe like me you are not a big social media person? I read a bit of news but I boycotted all social media except you tube since 2020.

                        _/\_
                        sat/ah
                        hōsai
                        ​​​

                        Comment

                        • Onkai
                          Senior Priest-in-Training
                          • Aug 2015
                          • 3169

                          #13
                          I have social media accounts, but follow music more than anything. I rarely go on social media and don't get my info there, just keep in touch with a few people and find entertainment.

                          Gassho Onkai
                          美道 Bidou Beautiful Way
                          恩海 Onkai Merciful/Kind Ocean

                          I have a lot to learn; take anything I say that sounds like teaching with a grain of salt.

                          Comment

                          • Onsho
                            Member
                            • Aug 2022
                            • 168

                            #14
                            I have a book recommendation for anyone interested.

                            Igniting a long-overdue dialogue about how the legacy of racial injustice and white supremacy plays out in society at large and Buddhist communities in particular, this urgent call to action outlines a...


                            Radical Dharma
                            By Rev. Angel Kyodo Williams
                            Lama Rod Owens
                            Jasmine Syedullah

                            Rev Angel is fully ordained in the Soto tradition, that being said she is the second Black woman on earth and the third Black person in America to be ordained in our tradition.

                            All three authors are wonderful writers. The writing is very accessible well also being very concise. It's intimate, personal and loving while also being fierce. It offers a lot of deep perspectives for anyone on any part of their journey. This book has cleared up so many of my personal conflicts with the world today and I feel grounded enough with myself that I'm able to reach out and support others once again.

                            Rev Angel is an excellent teacher for people that wish to participate in engaged Buddhism while keeping very much in line with the precepts. She also has a online course in April "Embodying Social Justice".

                            Gassho
                            Onshō
                            satlah
                            Last edited by Onsho; 02-07-2025, 12:11 AM.

                            Comment

                            • Hosai
                              Member
                              • Jun 2024
                              • 691

                              #15
                              Originally posted by Onsho
                              I have a book recommendation for anyone interested.

                              Igniting a long-overdue dialogue about how the legacy of racial injustice and white supremacy plays out in society at large and Buddhist communities in particular, this urgent call to action outlines a...


                              Radical Dharma
                              By Rev. Angel Kyodo Williams
                              Lama Rod Owens
                              Jasmine Syedullah

                              She also has a online course in April "Embodying Social Justice".

                              Gassho
                              Onshō
                              satlah
                              Went to a lecture she gave in Lewiston ME. She's legit!
                              ​​​
                              _/\_
                              sat/ah
                              hōsai

                              Comment

                              Working...